Emily Tan
Sep 10, 2015

Women may be holding themselves back out of guilt

SINGAPORE - Only 3 per cent of creative directors are women, and while the reasons are manifold and the problems systemic, one of the barriers for women could be their own feelings of guilt, according to a panel discussion at Spikes Asia today.

L-R: Jayme, Hockings, Paul and Powers
L-R: Jayme, Hockings, Paul and Powers

"I've asked other women in the industry, 'We're lacking in creative women, what is the barrier?'" said Merlee Jayme, chairman and chief creative officer, DM9 Jayme Syfu. "One woman said, 'I'm engaged, should I continue in this career?'. One even cried and asked, 'I'm pressured to have a baby, should I carry on?'. They look at a career in advertising as a demanding one, and at odds with having a family."

Being a mother and a high-powered advertising executive, agreed Suzanne Powers, CSO of McCann Worldgroup, "is a tonne of juggle."

"You hear so many little stories like these," said Josy Paul, chairman and CCO of BBDO India, who also appeared on the panel chaired by BBC presenter Lucy Hockings. "A CD leaves because her colleagues have told her that if she wants a relationship, she needs to break up because it's not going to work. Perception, whether true or not, is affecting the issue."

Some advice the panellists had for women and for agencies looking to help women develop in their careers:

  • Jayme: Let go of the guilt. You deserve what you've worked for.
  • Powers: Be proud of what you do. Don't play it down. The passion you have for what you do, when you bring home, creates a different kind of child.
  • Paul: Perhaps women should be compensated for the work they do at home too, so it's better appreciated.
  • Paul: Don't just talk about these ideas, put it in a brand campaign.
  • Jayme: You need a good team at work and one at home.
  • Powers: It's alright to be human at work. Don't overcompensate. Don't make it a case of "Pay no attention to the twins I just had. I can keep going!"
  • Paul: Create an environment that is more embracing if you want to maximise the potential of women.
  • Powers: We are not doing enough policy-wise. But attitudinally we've made a start. It's important to support men having babies as much as the women.

Campaign's view: While the topic was warmly and sincerely discussed, the conversation still revolved around "women helping women" rather than "society helping society help women".


Related Articles

Just Published

1 hour ago

Creative Minds: Why Eddy Nazarullah went mad for ads

The creative director at Reprise Malaysia answers 11 of our questions. Learn how his art teacher's husband set his destiny, why he admires Goku (from Dragon Ball) and Rocky, what he fears, and why he hasn't really seen NYC despite going there more than once.

2 hours ago

Weber Shandwick's APAC chairman departs after 17 years

Industry veteran Baxter Jolly will leave to explore professional and personal interests.

5 hours ago

Despite recent controversies, aesthetic diversity ...

SHANGHAI ZHAN PODCAST: Shiseido China’s Carol Zhou says that Chinese women are now more accepting of their own physical features and will be looking to beauty brands to improve them.

6 hours ago

POSB Bank aims to reach kids early with animated tales

The Singapore bank attempts to teach financial literacy with a series of stories created by The Secret Little Agency.