Jenny Chan 陳詠欣
Mar 17, 2017

CCTV's Muji claims denounced by Shanghai Quarantine Bureau

The plot has taken a twist with assertions of the opposite from both Muji and Shanghai authorities.

CCTV's Muji claims denounced by Shanghai Quarantine Bureau

The Shanghai Entry-Exit Inspection and Quarantine Bureau has said that, contrary to a report by CCTV, Muji did not import any food products from radiation areas in Japan.

After a CCTV report criticised the Japanese retailer (see "Nike, Muji targeted in China consumer rights exposé"), the bureau yesterday said it had carried out an inspection of Muji's operations and found no irregularities.

Muji’s Weibo account also issued an official response including certificates of origin of the products highlighted by CCTV showing raw materials sourced from Hokkaido and China, and processing done in Osaka and Fukui (the images are reproduced below).

Alex Tao, director of marketing and business development at 3insights Marketing Technology Consulting and an ex-SAP marketer, said the new information makes it appear CCTV deliberately took aim at Muji without proper evidence.

With the current business environment in China, there are more serious and urgent problems deserving of much more attention, he said, adding that this is a "hegemonic" way of manipulating public opinion.

“From a nationalistic viewpoint, priority placed on domestic goods is of course understandable, but CCTV cannot create chaos and bend the rules," Tao said. "There will be little meaning in watching this CCTV show [in future] due to its subjective judgments. The show is the legacy of last-century thinking and should be closed down, or turned over to quality-inspection or legal authorities to host. Being a mouthpiece of the country is not a problem; the problem is how CCTV avoids more important social concerns.” [Editor's note: Tao's comments have been translated from a WeChat exchange in Chinese.]

CCTV's report singled out Muji for mislabeling food products from a part of Tokyo where radioactive contamination was detected in 2015. However, the brand clarified that actually referred to the registered office address of Muji's parent company Ryohin Keikaku, not the origin of the products.


Campaign China

Related Articles

Just Published

15 hours ago

Agency Report Cards 2023: We grade 31 APAC networks

Campaign Asia-Pacific presents its 21st annual evaluation of APAC agency networks based on their 2023 business performance, innovation, creative output, awards, action on DEI and sustainability, and leadership.

15 hours ago

Ogilvy's Krishnan Menon joins RGA as SEA managing ...

Menon has stepped into the newly created position at RGA. He will continue to be based in Singapore and assume the role with immediate effect.

16 hours ago

The blurring lines between B2B and B2C marketing ...

CAMPAIGN 360: Marketers discuss how converging B2B and B2C strategies allow them to rethink and benefit from each other's insights and best practices.