Charles Wigley
Nov 13, 2017

Are we baking the cake, or just icing it?

If an agency's role is going to be limited, maybe we could waste less time in pitches, writes Charles Wigley of BBH.

Are we baking the cake, or just icing it?

It's a question I increasingly think we should ask at the start of pitches.

At this stage briefing documents are filled with talk of brand leadership, disruption and the like.

This, of course, is music to the ears of any agency worth its salt. It's a chance to change things, to improve the category, to move the whole game on. Good grief, even (but whisper it quietly) to leave some kind of advertising legacy. Many bold statements are made and brand vision statements crafted.

Then real work begins.

And it rapidly becomes clear that brand X isn't really in the business of changing the world, or challenging the category or even evolving itself.

And brand does not lead the business. In fact, the business is getting on absolutely fine, thank you. Making lots of cash without any necessity for marketing to actually change anything.

Marketing's job in this instance is to manage the development of advertising. To create the icing around a cake that's already been baked.

Because that is enough to make money in many categories in Asia at the moment. And it's a perfectly valid role for agencies and advertising (in fact the original role).

It's just that it might be better to get to that realisation quicker. Otherwise too much time is wasted on discussion about change that will never actually happen.

When competitive pressures start to make marketing here more "like a knife fight in a telephone box" (as Adam Morgan once memorably described it) then real product and brand evolution are far more likely to take place.

Until then it's probably best to keep those bags of icing sugar handy.

Charles Wigley is chairman of BBH Asia Pacific.


Related Articles

Just Published

1 day ago

Behind Spotify's new Southeast Asia campaign

EXCLUSIVE: Campaign talks to Jan-Paul Jeffrey, Spotify’s head of marketing, on the streamer's latest regional campaign for Indonesia, Thailand and Philippines.

1 day ago

Tech MVP 2022: Sunil Naryani, Dentsu

MOST VALUABLE PROFESSIONAL: Chief product officer Sunil Naryani has been instrumental in elevating the product offerings from Dentsu and driving radical collaborations across market product leaders.

1 day ago

Why purposeful creativity is more important than ...

Why do we still rush to come up with a once-in-a-lifetime brilliant stroke of genius that had zero impact on anyone’s life or business, and then proudly stand on a stage receiving accolades for our achievements? MediaMonks' APAC ECD ponders this question and more.

1 day ago

Here's Google's plan to to help advertisers manage ...

David Temkin, senior director of product management, ads privacy and user trust at Google, who is leading the charge on preserving ad targeting and measurement while tracking restrictions loom, discusses these shifts.