Staff Reporters
Dec 18, 2014

Best of 2014: Top 5 PR disasters

Our annual year-in-review series continues with the year's top 5 PR disasters

Best of 2014: Top 5 PR disasters

Campaign Asia-Pacific is presenting a new top-5 list every day until we send our last daily bulletin of the year on December 19. We've had fun pulling this annual review together, and we hope you'll enjoy it too.

Please follow along as we spotlight the year's highlights and lowlights. And if you think we've screwed up—either by inclusion or omission—please let us hear about it in the comments and/or on Twitter @CampaignAsia using the hashtag #CampaignBestOf2014.

<< See all 2014 year-in-review top-5 lists >>

Without further ado, here are the...

TOP 5 PR DISASTERS OF 2014

1 - Malaysia Airlines

The twin tragedies for Malaysia Airlines that happened this year have been a PR practitioner’s nightmare that exposed gaps in the government’s ability to handle communications around incidents of distress. The first incident—the disappearance of Flight MH370—was handled in a dreadful way with an assumptive text message to victims’ families. The second catastrophe, when MH17 was shot down, saw the airline being more cautious with its media responses. But all in all the events destroyed the Malaysia Airlines brand, which was left with little control over its own destiny.

2 - Chow Tai Fook

The jewellery retailer’s deputy head of public relations was not a good guardian of her own reputation. Joanna Kot, a name that the Hong Kong PR industry may remember for some time to come, made inflammatory comments regarding protesters who were sexually assaulted during the Occupy Central standoff. As her employer faced fallout from aggravated consumers, she was forced to resign from her post.

3 - National Council on Problem Gambling

Singapore’s anti-gambling ad became a global joke after the fictional betting scenario it featured turned into reality. The ad warned of the dangers of betting all your savings on an improbable result, such as, say, Germany winning the World Cup. That was exactly what happened as Germany took Brazil to the cleaners in the semi-finals. The Council tried in vain to salvage the situation by tweaking the copy to highlight how hard it is for hardcore gamblers to stop—even if they win unexpectedly.

4 - McPR fail

Like its fast-food peers, McDonald’s might be seen as a victim in the bad-meat saga that began in July, all thanks to rogue supplier Shanghai Husi. However, in Hong Kong, the brand violated several rules from the crisis-management playbook that resulted in a “large withdrawal from the bank of trust”, said one PR expert. McDonald’s first denied any relationship with the embattled supplier before being forced to admit it did when social media posts busted its lie with photographic evidence.

5 - Novartis Japan

Japan is one of Novartis’ biggest markets, but the pharmaceutical giant shot itself in the foot by admitting it did not report 2,579 cases of serious side effects in patients using its leukaemia and other cancer drugs. Novartis also allegedly misled consumers with ads citing research that was later found to be false. What’s worrying: the research in question was published in reputable international journals and peer-reviewed studies, despite the thorough sign-off procedures in place intended to ensure scientific integrity. Throughout all the scandals, the brand has referred all questions to its Swiss headquarters.

 

Related Articles

Just Published

5 hours ago

Reddit launches in-house agency to help brands tap ...

KarmaLab will offer workshops and insights for brands from Reddit users.

5 hours ago

Adlanders work long hours because clients don't pay ...

The D&AD chairman places the blame for adland's long-hours culture at the door of marketers.

5 hours ago

Chaka Sobhani promoted to global chief creative ...

Sobhani will still head up creative at Leo Burnett London.

17 hours ago

Forrester CMO pushes for tighter integration of ...

Marketers need to tighten up oversight over all the touchpoints in the buying journey, which has increased from 17 to 27 on average during the pandemic, according to Shirley Macbeth.