Staff Reporters
May 13, 2014

Ivory and dolphin meat: Rakuten’s sales policy raises questions

BRAND HEALTH CHECK: Trade in illegal animal goods shows the brand has work to do to become a truly global player.

EIA: The NGO’s ad on Rakuten’s whale and ivory sales
EIA: The NGO’s ad on Rakuten’s whale and ivory sales

Rakuten is one of a growing number of Japanese brands aiming to become as recognisable internationally as they are at home. But it now risks becoming known for the wrong reasons. The Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA) recently exposed thousands of ads for ivory, whale and dolphin meat on its site.

To its credit, the firm has since stopped the sales of whale and dolphin meat following an International Court of Justice order preventing Japan from whaling. But it continues to sell ivory.
Things have looked much better. Rakuten is a dominant e-commerce brand at home, and has a more progressive approach than many Japanese firms. But the company’s support of contentious industries indicates it may be out of touch with international sentiment, and it is not clear whether it is ready to become a truly global platform.

DIAGNOSIS 1 
David Ketchum
Asia-Pacific president
Bite

Rakuten is discovering that when you decide to go global, the rules change. Even if the sale of whale meat and some pre-1947 ivory is legal in Japan, offering the contentious products has unleashed a vocal group of activists worldwide. No company or nationality likes to be told what to do, but standing its ground based on Japanese laws and cultural standards could cause Rakuten to be perceived as an unethical brand and hamper its global ambitions.

From a communications perspective, Rakuten has shown little proactivity in addressing the protests, which is a missed opportunity and potentially a ticking brand time bomb. My advice for Rakuten is to drop the offending items completely, and create and announce clear and progressive legal and ethical policies about what is for sale on its sites.

Setting aside societal concerns, even if sales of these items are lucrative today, they amount to a small fraction of the site’s overall US$4 billion turnover. Rakuten has invested in international business expansion by acquiring properties such as Buy.com, Viber, and a stake in Pinterest. If international influencers target Rakuten, its expansion risks being blocked. The reputational risk, and management time and attention required to navigate through this thicket is not worth the effort and the distraction.

DIAGNOSIS 2 
Lou Hoffman
Chief executive
The Hoffman Agency

Expanding a brand from the home field to global markets is not a journey for the squeamish. Whether this single episode has damaged the Rakuten brand misses the point. Nourishing a global brand is a marathon, not a sprint. Does the company have the necessary mentality, infrastructure and communications expertise?

When a company owns the local market, as Rakuten does in Japan, it can breed a false sense of security. I’m not sure whether Rakuten appreciates what an emotionally charged issue this is outside of Japan. The initial Guardian story alone triggered nearly 1,800 social shares. Now, with the recent ruling by the International Court of Justice forcing Rakuten’s hand, the company has finally put a stop to the selling of whale meat.

It is revealing to look at Rakuten’s official statement: “In accordance with the ruling... Rakuten today asked merchants to cancel sales of whale meat products on [its] marketplace. [It] has also requested these merchants to remove all related items from their online shops within the next 30 days.”

It chose ‘clinical’ over ‘empathy’. Again, it’s tough for a brand to connect with consumer values across the world. Still, Rakuten will need to shift from clinical to empathetic communications to succeed in this branding marathon.

 

 

Related Articles

Just Published

15 hours ago

Campaign Crash Course: How Facebook's ad auction works

Understand the intricacies of the advertising auction powering one of the world's biggest platforms, with tips on how to 'game' the algorithm and best guarantee success.

15 hours ago

Comedians go Christmas shopping in humourless ...

A comedy cast in a Christmas campaign is a great idea on paper, but the execution for this one was as dry as overcooked turkey.

16 hours ago

Tinder fills India ad with hopeful meet-cute moments

A new campaign from BBH India focuses on the heady mixture of trepidation and hope involved in a series of first meetings, and it's inspired by real users of the app.

17 hours ago

Famous Innovations, Dentsu agencies lead field in ...

Famous Innovations bags the most gold wins, while Dentsu Webchutney wins the highest number of awards.