‘You had the entire rainbow’: Pantone’s ‘Cloud Dancer’ sparks creative criticism

Pantone has selected a shade of white for its Colour of the Year for the first time since the programme launched in 1999.

A muted off-white with grey undertones is Pantone's Colour of the Year. Called Cloud Dancer, the hue is meant to represent "softness, clarity, and quiet elegance," according to the colour authority. This is the first time the company has selected a shade of white for the designation.

"At this time of transformation, when we are reimagining our future and our place in the world, PANTONE 11-4201 Cloud Dancer is a discrete white hue offering a promise of clarity," Leatrice Eiseman, executive director of the Pantone Colour Institute, said in a statement, adding that the hue is meant to enhance focus and provide "release from the distraction of external influences."

The annual Colour of the Year is selected by a global team of colour specialists, who draw on signals across film and television, art, fashion, design trends, emerging technologies and materials, social media, and even major global sporting events to determine the hue that best reflects the coming cultural moment.

For marketers, Pantone's annual declaration often sets the creative tone for brands and campaigns for the year ahead. Several brands have already jumped on the bandwagon.

As always, the designation has landed with commercial force. Brands have already moved quickly. Play-Doh launched a limited-edition Cloud Dancer clay pot. Motorola has revealed a special-edition smartphone finished in the shade and embellished with Swarovski crystals. Spotify even curated a “bright, light, soft and clear” playlist inspired by the colour.

Motorola's Edge 70 X Swarovski in Cloud Dancer

Over recent years, Pantone's Colour of the Year palette has leaned more bold (see below). In 2023, Viva Magenta, a hot pink-red, was meant to celebrate self-expression. The following year, a sunwashed tone named Peach Fuzz was chosen to represent authenticity and optimism. For 2025, Mocha Mouse, a warm chocolate brown, resonated for its sense of indulgence. 

Against that backdrop, Cloud Dancer is a dramatic shift—less emotional saturation, more visual restraint.

Ironically, the choice of colour has not inspired a sense of calm in the creative community but ignited a debate with some marketers disapproving of the spectral white shade. In an industry facing constant upheaval with restructures, job cuts, and major takeovers, does it really need to be so dull—or is there still space and desire for boldness?

“All of us in advertising and marketing know that something like this doesn’t happen out of nowhere, and it’s connected to a bigger purpose, to a bigger idea that is slowly but surely penetrating society. This is not tone deaf. It’s intentional,” Natalia Casas, strategy director at Ogilvy, wrote on LinkedIn, criticising the selection.

She added: "And the irony is that many believe this only hurts my community—the communities of colour—when in reality it affects us all as humans. It’s never going to be white enough anyway."

Others were less restrained.

"Pantone has released its 2026 Colour of the Year. Guilty Remnant. I mean Cloud Dancer,” quipped Laura Davis Rinck, CEO of Rinck Advertising, referencing the minimalist cult in HBO’s The Leftovers. “Finally, a palette for those who prefer their emotions repressed. A soothing shade that whispers, ‘We are living reminders… but make it editorial.’ I’m sorry, Pantone, but read the room. You had the entire rainbow to dance in those clouds and you chose white to be the superior colour? Just no. Not this year or ever.”

Rachel Lowenstein, former global head of inclusive innovation at Mindshare, argued that the choice of a neutral felt political: "Pantone Colour of the Year is another marketing flop in a year of marketing flops."

"The visuals feel sterile and devoid of cultural context. The colour is… a choice… albeit not entirely wrong for the zeitgeist. I originally thought they were making a statement about the rise of fascism by choosing such an austere colour, but Pantone is a cultural institution that shapes culture—it doesn’t just react to it," she said, adding that she would have preferred "a fiery orange ember."

From a creative standpoint, is white even a colour? That's also a debate online. "I wonder if the folks at @pantone were told, as I was when I was a child, that white is not a colour... It's the absence of it," one person wrote on X.

Other marketers have responded with levity, noting that the hue reflects a sense of creative fatigue. "Basically… they discovered Bobcat Pallet Jack White. Finally, the warehouse is the most fashionable place to be. Who wears Pantone Colour of the Year ‘Cloud Dancer’ better? The model or the machine?” wrote Julie Clarke-Bush, fractional CMO of High Viz Marketing.

Still, not all voices were cynical, with several defending the subtle aesthetic as a response to years of loud, saturated design and branding. “In the gentle calm of Cloud Dancer, the peacock rises effortlessly, serene, and naturally supreme,” wrote Pavel Podder, senior art director at Brandwizz Communications.

“A reminder that true beauty doesn’t demand attention. It simply appears. Think Supreme. Mystery Today. Magic Tomorrow," Podder added. 

The Colour of the Year series first launched in 1999 with the sky blue shade Cerulean. Over two decades, Pantone has transformed a once-niche forecast into a global barometer of aesthetics. Looking ahead, Pantone plans to use Cloud Dancer as a “blank canvas" that spans artist collaborations and limited-edition designs to further cement its role as a gatekeeper in the creative space.

| pantone