PRIVATE VIEW: David Alberts, executive creative director at Mojo Partners, Sydney

<p>When asked to review this series of ads from around the world, my </p><p>private view was that this was a good excuse. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>A good excuse to remind people that I'm still alive and happy living in </p><p>a small island south of Asia. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>The Vodaphone ad is a very good excuse to find a reason to use some </p><p>pretty cool animation technique that saves the commercial from being at </p><p>best, a slice of life generic spot. The background provided with the ad </p><p>mentions that the agency has since lost the account. Wonder why? </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>If you stare at the Sci-Fi Channel idents long enough you will enter a </p><p>time zone that will take you to a place where people understand things </p><p>we don't. A bloody good excuse for meaningless crap. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>MTV Hits. No excuses here. Just good. In a world where MTV has become an </p><p>execution genre of idea-free commercials, it's good to see an MTV promo </p><p>with a really involving idea. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>The voiceover to the VW Microbus infomercial starts by saying, "it </p><p>started with an idea" and then makes no excuses for forgetting about the </p><p>idea and showing us two minutes of fantastic looking combi shots. The </p><p>new combi which is a cross between a bakelite toaster and an Apple </p><p>Macintosh looks fantastic. I may not buy the commercial but I'd love to </p><p>buy the vehicle. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>Maybe that's the idea. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>An idea, such as the one for Pizza Hut, that is so true to a product </p><p>promise that I feel as sick at the end of the ad as I know I am going to </p><p>feel at the end of the pizza. The beautifully seamless twisting camera </p><p>work leaves my stomach turning way before I see the horrific twisting </p><p>dipping excuse for a pizza. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>And finally, the Cadillac television commercial is just a very good </p><p>excuse for doing a car chase. It's not going to do anything for Cadillac </p><p>because it doesn't differentiate itself from other car chase TVCs. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>After going through this exercise I realised that as we enter another </p><p>slowdown or even a recession, there is an even greater need for creative </p><p>thinking and ideas and that we really have no excuse for some of the </p><p>meaningless executional indulgences that boom times bring. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>VODAFONE </p><p>Project: Night out </p><p>Client: Vodafone </p><p>Brief: Vodafone is for everyone </p><p>Agency: BMP DDB </p><p>Copywriter: Amber Casey </p><p>Art director: Dan Hubert </p><p>Production house: Studio AKA </p><p>SCI-FI CHANNEL </p><p>Project: Idents </p><p>Client: Sci-Fi Channel </p><p>Brief: Build the channel's brand image and positioning </p><p>Production company: Tsunami Films </p><p>Creative director: Tor McLaren (Sci-Fi Channel) </p><p>Art director: Don Cameron </p><p>MTV </p><p>Project: Eggcentric </p><p>Client: MTV Hits </p><p>Brief: To announce the launch of the MTV Hits Channel </p><p>Agency: Malcolm Moore Deakin Blazye </p><p>Creative directors: Guy Moore, Tony Malcolm </p><p>Copywriter: Gary Ruby </p><p>Art director: Nick Williamson </p><p>Production house: Gorgeous Enterprises </p><p>VOLKSWAGEN </p><p>Project: Microbus </p><p>Client: VW </p><p>Brief: To highlight the strengths of the VW brand </p><p>Agency: Arnold Worldwide </p><p>Creative directors: Ron Lawner, Tim Brunelle, Chris Bradley </p><p>Copywriter: Tim Brunelle </p><p>Art director: Chris Bradley </p><p>Production house: GAP Films </p><p>PIZZA HUT </p><p>Project: Twist apartment </p><p>Client: Pizza Hut </p><p>Brief: Launch of pizza with a twist-off, dippable crust </p><p>Agency: Abbott Mead Vickers, BBDO </p><p>Creative director: Peter Souter </p><p>Copywriter: Ben Kay </p><p>Art director: Cameron Blackley </p><p>Production house: The Pink Film Company </p><p>CADILLAC </p><p>Project: The Chase </p><p>Client: Cadillac Escalade </p><p>Brief: The launch of Cadillac's first 4X4 model </p><p>Agency: Radius Leo Burnett </p><p>Creative director: Marc Chalhoub </p><p>Copywriter: Nadim Dimashkieh </p><p>Art director: Toufic Bayhum </p><p>Production house: VIP Film Dubai </p><p><BR><BR> </p>

When asked to review this series of ads from around the world, my

private view was that this was a good excuse.



A good excuse to remind people that I'm still alive and happy living in

a small island south of Asia.



The Vodaphone ad is a very good excuse to find a reason to use some

pretty cool animation technique that saves the commercial from being at

best, a slice of life generic spot. The background provided with the ad

mentions that the agency has since lost the account. Wonder why?



If you stare at the Sci-Fi Channel idents long enough you will enter a

time zone that will take you to a place where people understand things

we don't. A bloody good excuse for meaningless crap.



MTV Hits. No excuses here. Just good. In a world where MTV has become an

execution genre of idea-free commercials, it's good to see an MTV promo

with a really involving idea.



The voiceover to the VW Microbus infomercial starts by saying, "it

started with an idea" and then makes no excuses for forgetting about the

idea and showing us two minutes of fantastic looking combi shots. The

new combi which is a cross between a bakelite toaster and an Apple

Macintosh looks fantastic. I may not buy the commercial but I'd love to

buy the vehicle.



Maybe that's the idea.



An idea, such as the one for Pizza Hut, that is so true to a product

promise that I feel as sick at the end of the ad as I know I am going to

feel at the end of the pizza. The beautifully seamless twisting camera

work leaves my stomach turning way before I see the horrific twisting

dipping excuse for a pizza.



And finally, the Cadillac television commercial is just a very good

excuse for doing a car chase. It's not going to do anything for Cadillac

because it doesn't differentiate itself from other car chase TVCs.



After going through this exercise I realised that as we enter another

slowdown or even a recession, there is an even greater need for creative

thinking and ideas and that we really have no excuse for some of the

meaningless executional indulgences that boom times bring.



VODAFONE

Project: Night out

Client: Vodafone

Brief: Vodafone is for everyone

Agency: BMP DDB

Copywriter: Amber Casey

Art director: Dan Hubert

Production house: Studio AKA

SCI-FI CHANNEL

Project: Idents

Client: Sci-Fi Channel

Brief: Build the channel's brand image and positioning

Production company: Tsunami Films

Creative director: Tor McLaren (Sci-Fi Channel)

Art director: Don Cameron

MTV

Project: Eggcentric

Client: MTV Hits

Brief: To announce the launch of the MTV Hits Channel

Agency: Malcolm Moore Deakin Blazye

Creative directors: Guy Moore, Tony Malcolm

Copywriter: Gary Ruby

Art director: Nick Williamson

Production house: Gorgeous Enterprises

VOLKSWAGEN

Project: Microbus

Client: VW

Brief: To highlight the strengths of the VW brand

Agency: Arnold Worldwide

Creative directors: Ron Lawner, Tim Brunelle, Chris Bradley

Copywriter: Tim Brunelle

Art director: Chris Bradley

Production house: GAP Films

PIZZA HUT

Project: Twist apartment

Client: Pizza Hut

Brief: Launch of pizza with a twist-off, dippable crust

Agency: Abbott Mead Vickers, BBDO

Creative director: Peter Souter

Copywriter: Ben Kay

Art director: Cameron Blackley

Production house: The Pink Film Company

CADILLAC

Project: The Chase

Client: Cadillac Escalade

Brief: The launch of Cadillac's first 4X4 model

Agency: Radius Leo Burnett

Creative director: Marc Chalhoub

Copywriter: Nadim Dimashkieh

Art director: Toufic Bayhum

Production house: VIP Film Dubai