Matthew Keegan
Aug 26, 2024

One year of Threads: Where does X's challenger stand among rivals?

Campaign explores how Threads has fared since its record-breaking launch including advantages for users so far and current setbacks for advertisers.

One year of Threads: Where does X's challenger stand among rivals?

Time flies, especially on social media. It's already been over a year since Threads launched—Meta's alternative to X (formerly Twitter)—which sparked a huge initial surge of interest in the text-based platform and broke records gaining 10 million users in just seven hours. 

Lauded as a welcome return to thought-initiating conversations online, Threads has racked up more than 175 million monthly active users in its first 12 months, but interest has gradually slowed, with the platform now adding around five million active users a month and still lagging some way behind its rival X in daily active users.

When Threads first launched, linking user accounts between Instagram and itself, it opened a unique window of opportunity called ‘underpriced attention', explains Miki Sim, director of platforms and culture at VaynerMedia APAC.

"For marketers, it was a prime moment to capture visibility as consumers flocked to explore the new app," says Sim. "Several of our clients in Australia seized this underpriced attention opportunity, becoming some of the first brands worldwide to establish a presence on Threads, and experiencing good growth and engagement during this period." 

While the growth of Threads has slumped compared to its record-breaking launch, with Elon Musk's X currently dogged in controversy and haemorrhaging users and advertisers at an alarming rate, experts say this could be the prime opportunity for Threads to pick up the mantle and become X's genuine rival.

"This is the ideal time for Threads to strike while the iron is hot as X becomes a less conducive space for brands and creators to thrive in," says Elly Lau, behavioural analyst at Canvas8. 

"For instance, in Japan, where X has long dominated, users who are frustrated with Elon Musk’s policies have been migrating to Threads as an alternative. While user growth has been tapering in 2024, brands are capitalising on this migration, and we’re seeing companies like Uniqlo and Starbucks buffing up their local market presence on the app."

Upping engagement
 
Data from We Are Social and Meltwater shows that the average time per month active users spend on Threads is 20 minutes, compared to TikTok's 31 hours and YouTube's 28 hours. While engagement might be low as the platform finds its feet and continues to build its user base, Threads is a digital 'safe space' that’s relatively untouched by commercial influence making it an ideal platform from a community management point of view.
 
 

"I think brands who are looking to have more personal conversations with their audience can do so on Threads," says Gina McKinnon, CEO of content at OMG APAC. "It gives brands an opportunity to get clever and original with their organic content. We have seen good success stories from a community management point of view."

With this in mind, there’s lots of room to play around with Threads’ multimedia features like polls, GIFs, and audio posts to drive real-time conversations with audiences. Specifically, there’s lots of potential for brand co-creation in ways that feel more organic than Instagram or TikTok. 

"One example of a brand that’s really leaning into this is Disney, which uses Threads as a tool to directly speak with fans through Q&A-style posts," says Lau. "This differs from its X page, which focuses more on straightforward content updates from the brand."  

 
 

Specifically, in APAC, Japan is a standout market for Threads. While the overall penetration rate is still only at 5%—far below X’s 44%—its numbers have been steadily growing over the past year with nearly 11 million users in the country. Notably, Nielsen data shows that Gen Y and Z users account for 41% of Threads users in Japan, with a notable skew towards young women (26%). 

India is also another emerging market when it comes to Threads usage, and local users have been gravitating towards the platform as a vehicle for fan expression. Indian users created more than 50 million tags around pop culture topics ranging from cricket to celebrities and OTT content, which demonstrates the platform’s potential to bring fandoms together. India’s Thread users also have an appetite for multimedia engagement on the platform—Meta reports that they’re more likely to mention another user and attach a video in their posts compared to the global average. 

Elsewhere in APAC, users are engaging with Threads in a way that resembles the town square model that Elon Musk had envisioned for X but couldn’t quite achieve. For instance, Hong Kong youths flocked to Threads for unfiltered commentary on the Paris Olympics after Gen Z fencer Ryan Choi went viral for his refreshingly candid social presence on the platform. 

On the other hand, the app has become the new LinkedIn for Vietnam’s Gen Zers who are crowdsourcing job opportunities and connecting with potential employers in a more stress-free context. And thanks to Threads’ micro-blogging format, the platform has also become a confessional space for the country’s anxious youth amid growing economic inequality and a challenging job market. Gen Zers are taking to Threads to exchange stories and advice about struggles in their daily life, harkening back to an old-school social media experience that came before the curated perfection of Instagram.
 
A viable competitor to X
 
Threads could become a real competitor to X in the long term, especially with its cross-platform advantages via its integration with Meta's other powerhouse social platforms like Instagram and Facebook. They are also enhancing cross-platform capabilities, allowing Instagram users to seamlessly share Reels or Posts directly to Threads. With Threads posts appearing on the Instagram feed, this interconnected ecosystem will likely sustain the platform until it’s ready for its next phase of global growth.

"I think Threads could become a real competitor to X in the long term, especially with its cross-platform advantages," says Prasit Kunanuphanchai, head of brand and digital planning at BBDO Bangkok. "However, for now, it needs to find a unique feature or compelling reason to encourage users to switch from X. Building a strong community, which takes time, is crucial to this effort."

Werner Iucksch, SVP, head of social, APAC at Media.Monks, says that the story of X vs Threads is a bit of a red herring. He believes what matters most is the value that either platform brings to consumers, and that a better discussion would focus on the role social media plays for the brand and which platforms suit that strategy best.

"Threads currently has a smaller footprint than X, but that isn’t necessarily a problem—we have clients who go strong on Discord, which is similarly in a stage of growth driven by a passionate user base and communities in gaming and crypto, and Reddit also has substantial community value," says Iucksch. "Line similarly has a limited size, but a solid footprint in markets such as Japan and Taiwan. For Threads, the question marketers face is what unique opportunities the platform offers that others don’t, like its cross-platform synergy with Instagram."

Back in June, Threads finally launched its API, meaning developers can build their own integrations into the app. In recent weeks, Threads has also been ramping up their monetisation push and launching tools like post-scheduling and performance analytics to help creators. 

"The problem is that right now, there’s only a very small pool of brands and creators who are posting consistently on Threads, so there isn’t as much engaging content volume-wise that will keep users on the platform compared to TikTok and Instagram," says Lau. "Seeing how there’s a general sense of fatigue and disillusionment among creators that sustainable monetisation is more difficult than ever, Threads should leverage its emerging appeal and demonstrate how they can support creators—especially smaller ones who may struggle to stand out in a very saturated influencer landscape."

Having a clear USP and point of differentiation that sets it apart from others is what Threads appears to be lacking. 

"I look forward to seeing Threads gain its footing on its journey to build value for more consumers and brands, but getting there will mean casting a clearer spotlight on what sets the platform apart from others," says Iucksch. “That will go a long way in helping marketers envision the role it plays in the social media mix." 

While Threads hasn't publicly launched an ad platform yet and has only run campaigns as part of limited tests, ads are expected to come this year with Mark Zuckerberg stating that paid ads and monetisation are coming once the app gets on a clear path toward one billion users.
 
 
It is still early days for Threads, making it difficult to predict its long-term trajectory in the competitive social platform landscape. However, its strongest advantage lies in its deep integration with the Instagram ecosystem.
 
"Looking ahead, Threads’ long-term direction is aligning with the 'fediverse', a concept that contrasts with today’s typical closed ecosystems," says Sim. "The fediverse emphasises interconnectivity, enabling cross-posting and content sharing across different social platforms. In March, Threads began rolling out fediverse integration with X competitors such as Mastodon in the US and Japan, marking the first step toward this broader vision. Whether the fediverse will gain significant momentum remains to be seen, but it’s an intriguing shift in the social media landscape."
 
Currently, it seems Threads' greatest challenge is finding more compelling reasons for users to stay on the platform.
 
"Threads certainly doesn’t have the same brand safety issues that we find on X—which is great—but safety isn’t the core challenge Threads faces," says Iucksch. "We hope they can crack the value proposition to attract more consumers and motivate them to spend more than the average 1:20-minute session. With continued innovation and a focus on unique user experiences, Threads is poised to grow and open up fresh, exciting ways for advertisers to connect with an expanding audience."
 

 

Source:
Campaign Asia

Related Articles

Just Published

20 hours ago

Uber India’s Shroff duo campaign: Throwback vibes ...

Fuel Content produced the ad films, while FCB India was the creative agency for the campaign.

21 hours ago

McDonald’s Singapore rallies youth to embrace ...

Launched on World Mental Health Day, the 'Lovin' Me' initiative aims to support youth mental wellness through music, podcasts, and resources, tackling the growing challenges of emotional well-being among young people.

22 hours ago

Creative Minds: Brett Colliver swapped design for ...

Dentsu New Zealand’s CCO loves chasing creative chaos, bold ideas, and a courtside seat at the next NBA game.

1 day ago

How brands can make dynamic pricing fairer for ...

Dynamic pricing is one of the hottest trends in e-commerce, but while it benefits brands by optimising profit margins, Campaign explores how it can be made fairer for consumers.