Internet World awards ring local, not regional, complains judging panel

<p>Hot off the heels of last month's Internet World Asia Industry Awards, </p><p>held in the Lion City, the cream of Asia's 'Net crop trod the red carpet </p><p>and awaited its accolades of regional excellence. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>In theory, at least. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>In practice, the gala affair rang distinctly local, offering </p><p>Singaporeans the chance to nominate Asia's stellar Internet players; </p><p>with home-grown talent viewed, mostly, as the regional benchmark. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>"A lot of the nominations were unknown to many of the judges, as they </p><p>were Singapore-based," said Ms Carolyn Ong, senior reporter of the South </p><p>China Morning Post's Technology Post, herself a judge. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>"The nominations didn't make sense - and the judges didn't have a say on </p><p>who we could nominate". </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>Audited by Price Waterhouse Coopers, the verdict on Tom.com's scoop of </p><p>Internet start-up of the year sent ripples of disbelief throughout </p><p>audience and judge ranks. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>Stunned responses ranged from "surprised" to "how, or why, did the hype </p><p>win out"? </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>Nevertheless, categories which characterised the awards included the </p><p>impact award for charitable contribution to the 'Net community - </p><p>watching seminar impressarios IandIAsia.com taking home the trophy. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>Tussling for pole-position in the Internet service provider of the year </p><p>category proved a tougher call - as then Cable & Wireless HKT (PCCW HKT) </p><p>and StarHub Internet reached an amicable tie. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>Saluting the finance providers that back Web promise, the investor/ </p><p>venture capitalist of the year was scooped up by Japan's Softbank; with </p><p>Malaysia's Asiatravelmart.com and Lion City business-to-business </p><p>services provider, WizOffice, tying neck-and-neck for the best ecommerce </p><p>company award. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>Breaking ground in the cluttered Web design market, the SAR's Lemon.com </p><p>won out for its innovative provision of emarketing and ebusiness </p><p>solutions; while Singapore's Creative Technology Ltd reigned supreme in </p><p>the hottest Internet hardware product category. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>India's Easydiary.com picked up the accolade for killer application of </p><p>the year for its Web-calendar and scheduling service. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>'Net stockbroker Boom.com proved its competitive edge, dominating the </p><p>best B2C Internet site category. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>Hitting the spot for Internet company of the year and best B2B Internet </p><p>site, the Lion City's Advanced Manufacturing Online (AMO) won out in the </p><p>high-tech manufacturing supply chain sector. </p><p><BR><BR> </p><p>Winning, and taking all, AMO chairman and CEO Mr Wong Toon King </p><p>continued the category wipe-outs - snapping up the highly-prized win of </p><p>Internet visionary of the year. </p><p><BR><BR> </p>

Hot off the heels of last month's Internet World Asia Industry Awards,

held in the Lion City, the cream of Asia's 'Net crop trod the red carpet

and awaited its accolades of regional excellence.



In theory, at least.



In practice, the gala affair rang distinctly local, offering

Singaporeans the chance to nominate Asia's stellar Internet players;

with home-grown talent viewed, mostly, as the regional benchmark.



"A lot of the nominations were unknown to many of the judges, as they

were Singapore-based," said Ms Carolyn Ong, senior reporter of the South

China Morning Post's Technology Post, herself a judge.



"The nominations didn't make sense - and the judges didn't have a say on

who we could nominate".



Audited by Price Waterhouse Coopers, the verdict on Tom.com's scoop of

Internet start-up of the year sent ripples of disbelief throughout

audience and judge ranks.



Stunned responses ranged from "surprised" to "how, or why, did the hype

win out"?



Nevertheless, categories which characterised the awards included the

impact award for charitable contribution to the 'Net community -

watching seminar impressarios IandIAsia.com taking home the trophy.



Tussling for pole-position in the Internet service provider of the year

category proved a tougher call - as then Cable & Wireless HKT (PCCW HKT)

and StarHub Internet reached an amicable tie.



Saluting the finance providers that back Web promise, the investor/

venture capitalist of the year was scooped up by Japan's Softbank; with

Malaysia's Asiatravelmart.com and Lion City business-to-business

services provider, WizOffice, tying neck-and-neck for the best ecommerce

company award.



Breaking ground in the cluttered Web design market, the SAR's Lemon.com

won out for its innovative provision of emarketing and ebusiness

solutions; while Singapore's Creative Technology Ltd reigned supreme in

the hottest Internet hardware product category.



India's Easydiary.com picked up the accolade for killer application of

the year for its Web-calendar and scheduling service.



'Net stockbroker Boom.com proved its competitive edge, dominating the

best B2C Internet site category.



Hitting the spot for Internet company of the year and best B2B Internet

site, the Lion City's Advanced Manufacturing Online (AMO) won out in the

high-tech manufacturing supply chain sector.



Winning, and taking all, AMO chairman and CEO Mr Wong Toon King

continued the category wipe-outs - snapping up the highly-prized win of

Internet visionary of the year.