ING Taiwan pits local incumbent in pitch shootout

TAIPEI: ING-Antai has put its life insurance account out for pitch in Taiwan, inviting multinational agencies - Saatchi & Saatchi, J. Walter Thompson, McCann-Erickson, BBDO and Results - to compete against local incumbent, Hsu & Chen Advertising.

The rules of engagement are somewhat unusual - Hsu & Chen will not pitch in the initial phase. The multinationals will pitch first with shortlisted agencies going up against the incumbent, which has held the account for six years and has created a series of award-winning TVCs.

"They told me that the winning multinational agency will pitch against us for the account,

said Peter Hsu, executive creative director of Hsu & Chen.

The multinationals appear to have a different take on the pitch. "It's a greater China brief, and the client wants one image across three markets,

said Raymond So, Asia-Pacific chairman of BBDO.

BBDO has serviced the account in Hong Kong since 1998, according to So.

The pitch underscores the key challenge confronting local agencies in Taiwan. "They are really in a jam,

said a source. "They made tons of money when Taiwan was hot. But as China opens up, most advertisers are looking at the entire Greater China market, and the local agencies lack the resources to serve clients outside the island."