Dec 14, 2001

Everbeauty's 20pc discount riles rivals

TAIPEI: Everbeauty, the in-house advertising arm of the Evergreen

Group, has sparked an uproar after it won the NT$160 million

(US$4.6 million) China External Trade Development Council (Cetra)

trade exhibition account by offering an unusually deep discount.



In what is seen as an industry first, Cetra requested agencies to pitch

on media price. Marketing strategy, media planning or creative

recommendations were not required for the review. When the bids were

opened, the industry was shocked to learn that Everbeauty won the

two-year assignment on a 20.11 per cent discount, meaning that the

$4.6 million account became a $3.68 million job.



Incumbent, Saatchi & Saatchi, presented an eight per cent discount,

while Regal and DY&R offered cuts of six and 5.6 per cent

respectively.



One agency participant said: "This wasn't a pitch. It was an auction. If

Everbeauty keeps the account but can't deliver its discount, it should

be fined."



The managing director of a competing agency added: "There is no way

Everbeauty can make a profit, no matter how it juggles the media."



Under Cetra's terms, all media discounts, including for volume and early

bookings, must be returned to the client before commission is paid. In

addition, Cetra's ads are normally placed in international print titles

which do not offer commissions in excess of 20 per cent.



Everbeauty declined to comment on its strategy.



Others expressed concerns that Cetra would allow Everbeauty to quietly

renegotiate once the uproar dies down. Some believe Everbeauty, as a

member of one of Taiwan's largest conglomerates, may have the clout to

do just that. Everbeauty was formed to publish the inflight magazine of

the group's airline. Although it handles a few client accounts, it

hardly ranks as a full-fledged agency, outsourcing for many services.



Everbeauty's 20pc discount riles rivals

TAIPEI: Everbeauty, the in-house advertising arm of the Evergreen

Group, has sparked an uproar after it won the NT$160 million

(US$4.6 million) China External Trade Development Council (Cetra)

trade exhibition account by offering an unusually deep discount.



In what is seen as an industry first, Cetra requested agencies to pitch

on media price. Marketing strategy, media planning or creative

recommendations were not required for the review. When the bids were

opened, the industry was shocked to learn that Everbeauty won the

two-year assignment on a 20.11 per cent discount, meaning that the

$4.6 million account became a $3.68 million job.



Incumbent, Saatchi & Saatchi, presented an eight per cent discount,

while Regal and DY&R offered cuts of six and 5.6 per cent

respectively.



One agency participant said: "This wasn't a pitch. It was an auction. If

Everbeauty keeps the account but can't deliver its discount, it should

be fined."



The managing director of a competing agency added: "There is no way

Everbeauty can make a profit, no matter how it juggles the media."



Under Cetra's terms, all media discounts, including for volume and early

bookings, must be returned to the client before commission is paid. In

addition, Cetra's ads are normally placed in international print titles

which do not offer commissions in excess of 20 per cent.



Everbeauty declined to comment on its strategy.



Others expressed concerns that Cetra would allow Everbeauty to quietly

renegotiate once the uproar dies down. Some believe Everbeauty, as a

member of one of Taiwan's largest conglomerates, may have the clout to

do just that. Everbeauty was formed to publish the inflight magazine of

the group's airline. Although it handles a few client accounts, it

hardly ranks as a full-fledged agency, outsourcing for many services.



Source:
Campaign Asia
Tags

Related Articles

Just Published

20 hours ago

Spikes Asia unveils its 2024 Creativity Report

This year's top agencies include VML in Melbourne, Ogilvy in Mumbai, Dentsu in Tokyo, and more.

22 hours ago

Creative Minds: Zosia Ella Kilpatrick's quest for ...

An active surfer, a weekend gardener and a wellness enthusiast, the award-winning MullenLowe creative shares secrets to inner peace.

22 hours ago

'Why should I worry about benchmarking against ...

Exclusive: Marketing agency R K Swamy's chairman and MD Srinivasan Swamy delves into the details of the company's pioneering IPO listing in India, and why he's focused on where to invest next in tech.

1 day ago

Agency Report Cards 2023: We grade 31 APAC networks

Campaign Asia-Pacific presents its 21st annual evaluation of APAC agency networks based on their 2023 business performance, innovation, creative output, awards, action on DEI and sustainability, and leadership.