Emily Tan
Aug 23, 2012

Regional media buyers dispute Warc’s report on APAC's 'plunging' marketing budgets

ASIA-PACIFIC – Although Warc’s latest global marketing index (GMI) shows that marketing budgets in the region have dropped ‘significantly’ in August, media specialists in the region have noticed no change in client ad spend.

Regional media buyers dispute Warc’s report on APAC's 'plunging' marketing budgets

Warc reported that marketers have ‘declining confidence’ in the Asia-Pacific region, where budgets have ‘generally decreased’, giving the region an index score of 46.0, down from 50.8 last month. (In the Warc report, a reading of 50 is neutral.) 

This pulled down the headline GMI measure—which combines readings for trading conditions and staffing levels alongside marketing budgets—for Asia-Pacific down to 52.6 from 53 last month. 

Commenting on the August 2012 GMI results, Suzy Young, data editor at Warc, said: "In the months ahead, it will be interesting to see if the sudden dip for Asia Pacific is representative of a more deep-rooted downturn."

Malcolm Hanlon, COO for Asia-Pacific at Zenith Optimedia told Campaign Asia-Pacific that the media agency has not seen evidence of a ‘big downturn’ in August. “Everyone’s cautious, and there’s a little bit of feeling that China’s factory output may be slowing down, but consumers are still upbeat,” he said. “As long as consumers are still spending, marketing budgets aren’t affected that much.”

Hanlon added that he had just been in Hong Kong and the mood on the ground was as busy as he’s “ever seen”. He added that the report by Warc seemed rather negative. According to Admango, Hong Kong’s ad spend for the first half of 2012 alone was US$2.4 billion, a year-on-year increase of 13 per cent.

In July, Zenith Optimedia released its 2012 ad spend growth forecast, which downgraded Asia-Pacific slightly from 7.4 per cent this year to a still robust 6.7 per cent. According to the forecast, Japan is expected to report growth of 3 per cent this year, China growth of 14.5 per cent and India growth of 6.8 per cent.

Bharad Ramesh, Starcom Mediavest Group’s regional executive director, strategic operations and trading, Asia, told Campaign Asia-Pacific he has not noticed a slowdown for the Southeast Asian region. “I think India, China and Australia will hold the key given the size of spends in these markets,” he commented.

eMarketer sees no sign of slowing down for China’s ad spend. In its 1 August forecast, it predicts that China will grow by nearly 20 per cent to US$46.34 billion and expects the market to overtake Japan as Asia-Pacific’s largest next year. The report also expects growth of 3.2 per cent for Australia.

“As for the report itself, Asia-Pacific’s GMI is still tracking about 50, so there’s still growth,” added Ramesh.

Warc itself said in its GMI report for July that the budgets for Asia-Pacific were improving and that the outlook is positive. 

“The region has a lot of momentum and that doesn’t stop in one month,” said Hanlon.

Campaign Jobs

Follow us

Top news, insights and analysis every weekday

Sign up for Campaign Bulletins

Related Articles

Just Published

Premium
Publicis returns to organic growth in second quarter
Premium
5 hours ago

Publicis returns to organic growth in second quarter

Organic revenue grew 0.8 percent despite weak FMCG sector.

Premium
'Clean and green' driving NZ brand growth in Asia
Premium
5 hours ago

'Clean and green' driving NZ brand growth in Asia

Thanks to focus on provenance and health, New Zealand brands are punching well above their weight throughout Asia, according to Carl Stephens, managing director at Baldwin Boyle Shand.

Premium
A day in the shopping life of a young affluent Chinese man
Premium
5 hours ago

A day in the shopping life of a young affluent ...

Come along on a shopping expedition in NYC to see how a young, wealthy Chinese man approaches luxury brands.

Premium
Programmatic pants
Premium
6 hours ago

Programmatic pants

Carat's Clay Schouest shares a chilling vision of a future where machines make all choices—right down to your unmentionables.